Two of the finest poets to emerge from the Buffalo area literary scene in the 1980s return on Wednesday to read in Earth Daughter's Gray Hair Reading Series at 7:30 p.m. at Hallwalls, 341 Delaware Ave. (near Tupper). Both Anne Elezabeth Pluto and Nita Penfold are strong, independent-minded feminist writers very much in the tradition of Buffalo's Earth's Daughters Collective.
Although both happen to live in the greater Boston area now, there's a lot more than geographical proximity that makes them an appropriate pairing for the Gray Hair Reading Series. While their work differs quite markedly in form, these women are at the forefront of contemporary writing on spirituality and religious themes from a feminist perspective.
Anne Elezabeth Pluto, a Brooklyn native of Russian Orthodox heritage who lived in Buffalo from 1976 to 1983, earned her Ph.D at the University at Buffalo (her mentors were Robert Creeley, Leslie Fiedler and Art Efron) and co-programmed (with yours truly) Hallwalls' "Fiction Diction" Reading Series from 1981 to 1983. A poet (The Frog Princess and Unnatural Acts), playwright (I Enjoy Being a Girl), Shakespeare scholar and fiction writer, she is now professor of theater and literature at Lesley University in Cambridge, Mass., where she founded and is artistic director of the Oxford Street Players, a Shakespeare-based theater company.
As a longtime friend, I must admit to a certain bias in reading her work. That said, by any objective measure the work is extraordinary in both its language and its world-view. There is a powerful sense of ritual, tradition, and religiosity in her poems, and anyone who reads them closely will be impressed by how successfully she integrates Orthodox Christian imagery and iconography with bodily experience to create an eroticism of everyday life.
In her collection Unnatural Acts, the mysteries of the spirit and the mysteries of the flesh converge through the transforming power of language. What she does with the Russian Orthodox symbology of her faith—her subtle inversions and subversive feminist readings of it—are absolutely original in my reading experience. No one I know writes more effectively about cultural identity, the politics of personal intimacy, or the carnal manifestations of religious bliss.
Stylistically, Pluto favors Open Form--short, dense, breath-determined but expressive lines featuring strong images and powerful, sometimes incantatory cadences. Her recent work shows some Dickinsonian influence--particularly in its extensive use of dashes--but there is such self-assuredness in her voice that she is confident in taking risks that would terrify lesser poets. Imagine for a moment that Anna Akhmatova had somehow decided to flee Stalinist St.Petersburg and miraculously ended up at Black Mountain College in the 1950s with Charles Olson, Robert Creeley, Denise Levertov, et al. That voice would sound a whole lot like Annie's.
Here she is, for instance, (click on link) Reading "Unnatural Acts"
Nita Penfold grew up in Buffalo's Southtowns and came onto the literary scene here as a talented young writer (she was known as Bonita or even "Bonnie" back then) chiefly through her involvement with Earth Daughters and the former Niagara-Erie Writers. By the late 1980s, she had moved to New England, received her master's degree in creative writing at Lesley University (where Anne Pluto, coincidentally, had been hired) and began what has become her life's journey exploring the ways in which art and literature help us to understand both the nature of divinity and our experience of it.
In my 20 years of selecting the poems for The Buffalo News Poetry Page, she has become perhaps the most faithful and popular of our exiled "Buffalo native" contributors, and the range of her other writing and teaching activities is almost too extensive to keep track of. Her collections of poetry include “Mile High Blue Sky Pie” (Pudding House, 1998), “Woman With The Wild-Grown Hair” (Pudding House, 2002) and “They Stand Up in Broken Shells”, winner of the 2006 Writer’s Digest Self-published Book Award. In 2004, she edited the anthology "Hunger Enough: Living Spiritually in a Consumer Society" for Pudding House Press.
From a formal standpoint, her work recalls Free Verse in its vernacular style, and Whitman's long lines and expansive projections of the spirit in particular. Penfold, who received her doctor of ministry degree in creation spirituality in 2002, explores the idea of a gender-neutral, antinomian theology expressed not through rhetoric, but gentle humor and a profound appreciation for the spirituality that resides in the particulars of our common experience.
Recent Comments